Vietnam Made Him; Review of Colin Powell's My American Journey

Review

From the issue

As members of the Washington elite go, Colin Powell is an exceptionally attractive person. Apart from his great skills as a tactician and manager, and his talent as a politician, he has an outstanding zest for life that causes him to stand out. George Shultz, who worked closely with him, and who is a good judge, wrote in his account as Secretary of State, Turmoil and Triumph: "Colin Powell . . . was wonderful, savvy, smart, straightforward, and energetic. . . . As deputy [National Security Advisor], Powell had proved to be extraordinarily knowledgeable and gifted intellectually. He had a great touch with Congress."

Unhappily, he also reveals a mindset that produced poor judgments on some major events that occurred on his watch as Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.

Given the hoopla about his presidential prospects, many readers looked for clues on the kind of president he might make, and for his positions on such current issues as affirmative action, abortion, welfare, and the like. The hot button issues aside, his book does tell us important things about the capacities and attitudes Powell would bring to high political office, if he ever seeks it.

Most Americans by now must know the basic outline of his life: How a black boy from the South Bronx--before it became Fort Apache--progressed from the New York City schools, to high achievement in the ROTC program at City College of New York, and to a successful career in the army, ending up with the highest rank of the military establishment (the first ROTC member to achieve that position).

This is a premium article

You must be a subscriber of The National Interest to continue reading. If you are already a subscriber, activate your online access

Not a subscriber? become a subscriber to access this article.

Need to renew your subscription? Please click here.

More by

Follow The National Interest

June 18, 2013