The 5 Most Deadly Navies in Asia
Asia has some of the world’s best militaries—their navies are no exception.
But how does one rank them? Any ranking of military force obviously requires parameters. When we say best, what exactly do we mean? The quantity of arms or the quality? The number of platforms, their firepower and their age? Or the doctrine that accompanies their use and the training and morale of their operators?
All important considerations, to which we should add: how far does the military force in question enable the policy aims of its civilian overlords? Or conversely, how does it limit the country’s options?
An examination of Asia’s navies—or more precisely, navies that operate regularly in Asian waters—puts these questions in the spotlight, not least because there is a massive disparity in the size and quality of the maritime forces in question. In a (highly hypothetical) fight between, say, India and Singapore, you’d expect the Indian Navy (IN) to best the Republic of Singapore Navy (RSN): it’s got bucketloads of experience, more ships, more manpower and more money to buy or build replacements.
But which is the better navy? In qualitative, operational and policy-making terms, you’d say Singapore’s. And that’s why the RSN in is in this top five list, and the IN doesn’t make the cut, despite its heritage, history, two aircraft carriers and imminent commissioning of a nuclear-armed submarine.
5. South Korea:
South Korea has big ambitions for its navy and it is supporting these with major investments. In recent years, it has turned the Republic of Korea Navy (RoKN) from what was essentially a littoral patrol force into an emerging blue-water navy that can protect its offshore islands, sea-lanes (and thus economic interests) and play a role in international maritime projects, whether humanitarian assistance and disaster response (HADR) or anti-piracy operations off Somalia.
The navy’s reputation for coastal defense—its primary mission—was damaged by the sinking of the corvette Chon An in the Yellow Sea (West Sea) in March 2010, most likely by a North Korean torpedo. To its credit, Seoul responded quickly with a defense-reform plan that created a new command structure for the disputed West Sea region and bolstered anti-submarine warfare capabilities.
Beyond its immediate responsibility to deter and interdict North Korean activities, the RoKN is also building a formidable fleet that can operate globally. Fifteen destroyers, twelve of which will be equipped with the Aegis Weapon System, up to twenty-four Incheon-class frigates and a new generation of attack submarines make the RoKN one of the world’s more potent offshore forces, while the RoK Marine Corps is provided with one Dokdo-class amphibious assault ship, with a second reportedly on the way.
So the kit is present, but what about training and operational capabilities? The navy supports South Korean international outreach efforts—a South Korean flag officer has commanded the multinational counterpiracy Combined Task Force 51 three times to date, while the RoKN also provides an excellent shop window for Seoul’s burgeoning presence in the international-defense trade. While budgetary issues could curtail its ambitions, for the moment, South Korea’s navy seems to be putting its money where its mouth is.
4. Republic of Singapore Navy:
Singapore has spent the last fifty years showing Southeast Asia that the adage “quantity has a quality all of its own,” isn’t necessarily accurate when deterrence is involved.
The Republic of Singapore Navy (RSN) is just one element of the city-state’s considerable qualitative military superiority over its neighbors—a superiority that, along with smart diplomacy and alliance building, gives it an almost-impregnable defensive shield.
As well as providing defense for Singapore’s 193-km coastline, the RSN can also provide offshore defense of sea-lanes and plays a vital role in regional HADR operations. Six state-of-the-art frigates, six corvettes, five submarines (with two more on order), four amphibious landing ships, four mine warfare vessels and numerous patrol craft (and new versions in the pipeline) provide the hardware for crews that are motivated, well trained and enjoy a good reputation, both at home and abroad.
3. Japan Maritime Self-Defense Force:
Until recently, the largest navy in Northeast Asia, the JMSDF, has a well-earned reputation as a world leader in anti-submarine and mine warfare, although the threat from North Korean ballistic missiles led it to devote resources to build a fleet of Aegis-equipped ballistic-missile defense destroyers (now six, with two more planned) that in some eyes diluted its primary mission of maritime superiority.
That appears to be back in the spotlight, thanks to China’s newfound sense of itself as a maritime power. Japan has responded by increasing its submarine fleet from sixteen to twenty-two boats and boosting its combined destroyer and frigate fleet from forty-seven to fifty-four ships. It is also investing heavily in new Kawasaki P-1 maritime patrol aircraft, and more Sikorsky-Mitsubishi SH-60Ks and AgustaWestland MCH101 naval helicopters.