What Might Have Happened If Theodore Roosevelt Didn't Die So Soon

By Pach Bros. - This image is available from the United States Library of Congress's Prints and Photographs divisionunder the digital ID ppmsca.35645.This tag does not indicate the copyright status of the attached work. A normal copyright tag is still req
November 5, 2019 Topic: History Region: Americas Blog Brand: The Buzz Tags: U.S. PresidentHistoryTeddy RooseveltPoliticsLeague Of Nations

What Might Have Happened If Theodore Roosevelt Didn't Die So Soon

Could he have become President again?


A navy second to none exceeded the Mahanian standard. So much the better from Roosevelt’s standpoint if a naval accord could be brokered to lock in parity with Great Britain’s Royal Navy and superiority over the Imperial Japanese Navy—as indeed an arms-control treaty negotiated in Washington, DC did by 1922. The Washington Naval Conference, then, may well have gone forward under TR in much the same way it did under Warren Harding. Roosevelt would have been entirely comfortable with the pact—again, provided he satisfied himself that it was enforceable and thus worth more than the scrap of parchment on which it was inscribed.

So . . . my guesswork is that a Theodore Roosevelt v2.0 presidency would have proved less eventful than purveyors of alt-history might posit. It would have taken herculean politicking for him to make it back to the Oval Office in the first place. And if he did, he would have found the political climate far less congenial than in 1901–1909, when he headed an established political party and could use that leverage to move initiatives through Congress. In short, the President Roosevelt of the 1920s would have been an incremental—not revolutionary—chief magistrate.


A status quo presidency? That prospect would dismay the Colonel.

James Holmes is J. C. Wylie Chair of Maritime Strategy at the Naval War College and the author of Theodore Roosevelt and World Order (2006). The views voiced here are his alone. This first appeared in July 2019.

Image: Wikipedia.