Can Russia and America Avoid a New Nuclear Arms Race?

July 16, 2019 Topic: Security Blog Brand: The Buzz Tags: RussiaNew STARTMilitaryTechnologyNuclear Arms Race

Can Russia and America Avoid a New Nuclear Arms Race?

Then New Start must get an extension. 


Delegations from the United States and Russia plan to meet in Geneva in mid-July 2019 to begin discussing a possible extension of the New START treaty, one of the major arms-control accords limiting the size and power and the U.S. and Russian nuclear arsenals.

The 2010 treaty restricts both the United States and Russia to 1,550 deployed strategic nuclear warheads on a maximum of 700 deployed intercontinental ballistic missiles and strategic bombers.


But the treaty expires in 2021. And experts worry that the administration of U.S. president Donald Trump, in particular Trump’s national security advisor John Bolton, plans to sabotage a possible extension in order to allow for unlimited atomic rearmament.

“Before the Group of 20 summit last month in Japan, Russian president Vladimir Putin said he planned to push Pres. Donald Trump for an extension to New START,” The Associated Press reported. “Putin said his nation was ready to agree to an extension, but that Russia had not seen any initiative from the Americans even though the treaty expires in 2021.”

“Trump’s national security team has dithered for more than a year on beginning talks with Russia to extend [New START] before it expires in February 2021,” wrote Daryl Kimball, an expert with the Arms Control Association in the United States.”It is now apparent that Bolton is trying to steer Trump to discard New START.”

“There's no decision, but I think it's unlikely,” Bolton said of New START in a June 2019 interview.

“Without New START, there would be no legally binding, verifiable limits on the U.S. or Russian nuclear arsenals for the first time in nearly half a century,” Kimball pointed out.

David Axe serves as Defense Editor of the National Interest. He is the author of the graphic novels  War Fix,War Is Boring and Machete Squad.

John Sullivan, a deputy secretary of state, will lead the American delegation in Geneva, comprising officials from the State Department, National Security Council, Defense Department, Joint Chiefs of Staff and the National Security Agency.

Russian deputy foreign minister Sergei Ryabkov will lead his own country’s delegation. That talks are taking place just months after Trump withdrew the United States from the 1987 treaty limiting U.S. and Russian intermediate-range, land-based nuclear weapons.

The Trump administration’s cover story for possible sabotage of New START is that it wants a new, three-way nuclear-weapons pact. But negotiating a three-way treaty could take years and should not preclude an extension of New START.

"It would malpractice to discard New START in the hopes of negotiating a more comprehensive, ambitious nuclear arms control agreement with Russia and China and getting it ratified and into force," Kimball told The Associated Press.

“Bolton’s malign influence on U.S. arms control and international security objectives requires that Congress make it clear that the evisceration of common-sense arms control is unacceptable,” Kimball wrote.

A bill introduced by a bipartisan coalition led by House Foreign Affairs Committee Chairman Eliot Engel (D-N.Y.) and Rep. Mike McCaul (R-Texas), the committee’s ranking member, calls for extending New START as long as Russia remains in compliance, or until a new treaty that “provides equal or greater constraints” enters into force.

It would also require intelligence assessments of how New START’s expiration would affect the size and posture of Russian nuclear forces and of the additional intelligence capabilities that would be needed to compensate for losing the treaty’s extensive transparency and on-site monitoring provisions.

Meanwhile, Sens. Edward Markey (D-Mass.) and Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) have launched a bill to prohibit any funding for nuclear weapons that would violate New START limits as long as Russia continues to stay below treaty ceilings. Such an approach would guard against a breakout by either side and help to maintain strategic stability.

The stakes are enormous.  “If Trump continues to listen to Bolton’s advice and allows New START to expire,” Kimball explained, “he will likely become the first president since John Kennedy to fail to conclude at least one agreement with Russia to reduce nuclear dangers, and he will have opened the door to a new and dangerous nuclear arms race.”

David Axe serves as Defense Editor of the National Interest. He is the author of the graphic novels  War Fix,War Is Boring and Machete Squad.