1

Pyongyang’s Prisoner Release Is a Positive Step—but Only a First Step

May 9, 2018 Topic: Security Region: Asia Tags: HostagesNorth KoreaKim Jong UnNuclearSummitWar

Pyongyang’s Prisoner Release Is a Positive Step—but Only a First Step

Pyongyang is not immune from criticism on its human-rights record.

Secretary of State Mike Pompeo’s second trip to Pyongyang was remarkably productive. Not only did he nail down a date and location for the highly anticipated U.S.–North Korea summit, he also managed to secure the release of three American hostages.

Joining Pompeo on the flight back to Washington were Kim Dong-chul, Tony Kim and Kim Hak-song—three Americans who were sentenced by North Korea to hard labor on trumped-up charges of political crimes. Kim Dong-chul, a pastor, was convicted of spying in April 2016 and sentenced to ten years hard labor. Tony Kim and Kim Hak-song, professors at Pyongyang University of Science and Technology, were taken into custody in early 2017. The former was charged with espionage, the latter with “hostile acts.”

Calls to release the three prisoners took on new urgency last year after Americans witnessed the effects of North Korean detention on another American, twenty-two-year-old college student Otto Warmbier. North Korean authorities released him last June, sending him home in a comatose state. He died within days of his arrival.

Warmbier’s tragic death was a wake-up call to many Americans who previously did not know about—or felt removed from—the abuses committed regularly by the North Korean regime.

What is so encouraging about North Korea’s decision to release the three Americans is what it signals: that the regime is not immune from criticism on its human rights record. Their release should embolden U.S. negotiators to raise other pressing human rights issues at the summit.

The United States should also take great pains to communicate to North Korea that there will be consequences if the Kim regime should once again take Americans hostage. The odds of that happening were sharply reduced when the United States imposed a travel ban following Warmbier’s return. It greatly discouraged the average traveler from venturing into North Korea. Still, it is possible that Pyongyang might once again incarcerate visiting Americans if the regime feels it might give them leverage in their dealings with Washington.

It is not sufficient, however, for the Trump administration to address human rights concerns only as they pertain to the regime’s treatment of Americans. After all, Pyongyang authorities continue to hold hostage citizens from Japan and South Korea, our two great regional allies.

Moreover, the regime’s severe abuse of its own people deserves to be more than a footnote in upcoming talks. North Korea’s political prison camps hold 80,000 to 120,000 in captivity—in conditions rivalling those of Nazi Germany’s concentration camps or the Soviet gulags. The United States should highlight this aberrant behavior.

Negotiators should consider pressing for humanitarian access to the prisoners in those camps and taking steps that encourage North Korea to eventually shutter prison camps for good. It’s a critical issue—literally a matter of life or death for thousands, if not tens of thousands, of North Koreans.

 

President Trump denounced North Korea’s human rights abuses in his State of the Union Address. And Vice President Mike Pence poignantly revived the issue by inviting Otto Warmbier’s father to join him for the opening ceremonies of the Winter Olympics in South Korea.

But the administration has thus far given little indication that human rights will be a topic of discussion at the upcoming summit. South Korea failed to broach the topic during the inter-Korean summit on April 27. The United States should not repeat Seoul’s mistake.

 

Pyongyang’s release of the three prisoners is a positive step—a goodwill gesture that signals a willingness to negotiate at the upcoming summit. However, it is nothing more than that: a first step.

The road to denuclearization is a long one. The road to ridding North Korea of human rights abuses is even longer. But even the longest journey begins with a single step.

The U.S.-North Korea summit offers the opportunity for taking the necessary second step. It is the right moment to raise human rights and communicate to the Kim regime that North Korea will not earn legitimacy if it continues to violate the most basic rights of the North Korean people.

Olivia Enos is a policy analyst specializing in human rights and transnational criminal issues for The Heritage Foundation’s Asian Studies Center.

Image: U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo is greeted by senior North Korean official Kim Yong Chol, director of the United Front Department, which is responsible for North-South Korea affairs and Foreign Minister Ri Su Yong, on his arrival in Pyongyang, North Korea May 9, 2018. Pompeo met with North Korean leader Kim Jong Il later and secured the release of three American prisoners ahead of a planned summit between Kim and President Donald Trump. Matthew Lee/Pool via REUTERS