The effort to slander Chuck Hagel and to torpedo his potential nomination to be secretary of defense has reached such intensity that there is now much more at stake in this nomination than just who will be running the Pentagon over the next four years. Robert Merry in these spaces has portrayed well the sordidness of the calumny-flingers who make little effort to hide their main reason for going after Hagel, which is that he does not believe in subordinating U.S. interests to the wishes of the right-wing Israeli government and its American backers. Those in the anti-Hagel campaign who try to make it look as if there are non-Israeli reasons to shoot him down make arguments that move from the sordid to the ridiculous. The Washington Post's editorial on the subject is a good example. It tries to portray the former Republican senator from Nebraska as some kind of leftist peacenik, because he suggests there is some trimming that could usefully be done to U.S. defense spending (which is greater than the next 14 biggest military spenders—friends and foes—put together, and is the highest in inflation-adjusted dollars that it has been since World War II) and expresses skepticism about going to war against Iran (which the Post's editorialists acknowledge they have also expressed skepticism about, but that doesn't stop them from portraying the skepticism as somehow a point against Hagel). For a more thorough dismantling of this absurd editorial, see Andrew Sullivan's exegesis of it.
To the extent the placing of Hagel's name in the kind of unofficial nomination it is in right now was the result of deliberate balloon-floating by the White House, it is hard to see exactly what the White House thought it was doing. Making the nomination official and letting Hagel speak for himself would do a lot to puncture the falsehoods and smears about him. Maybe letting his name get out as the leading potential nominee was less a calculated act than plain old sloppy leaking. If one wants to give the White House more credit than that, one might postulate that it floated the name so the opponents would have a chance to discredit themselves so much through the sheer outrageousness of their arguments that they would not only lose this political battle but also be weaker in later ones. That way the president might get not only the secretary of defense he wants but also some more running room on issues such as the Iranian nuclear program and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
There is some valid logic to that. But such bold political jiu-jitsu does not seem to be this president's usual style. He is more likely to be thinking in the customary way, as discussed by Peter Baker in the New York Times, about conserving political capital, picking one's fights carefully, and keeping in mind all the other issues he may have to fight about (and he just got another one: gun control).
If the president applies to the nomination of a defense secretary a cautious approach grounded in such thinking, he would be making a mistake. He would be acting without sufficient appreciation for how intimidation works. Intimidation feeds on itself, with successful intimidation encouraging more of the same and failures discouraging further attempts. Neither Chuck Hagel nor anyone else has a right to any cabinet post, but given how this matter has already evolved, if the president now does not nominate him for the defense job it will be universally seen as a caving in to the neocons and Netanyahuites. Mr. Obama will be politically weaker as a result. He will have lost political capital rather than having conserved it. And he will have encouraged more such intimidation in the future.
Conversely, standing up to the intimidators and pushing a Hagel nomination through to confirmation would improve his ability to battle against the same forces on other issues. Even if the White House did not plan it that way, it would be a political plus for the president. More importantly, it would be a blow for decency and reason and a setback for one of the more damaging and tawdry features of American politics.
It is hard to imagine any future issues offering a conspicuously better place to draw a line in the sand and to start pushing back than this one. Based on what has already been said, there is reason to hope that the tawdriness—as James Fallows puts it in an insightful piece on this subject—“has finally gone so far that it will impeach itself.” It impeaches itself with arguments such as that a United States senator or cabinet member putting U.S. interests ahead of the interests of a foreign country or the wishes of a foreign government is somehow a bad thing.
Image: Flickr/State Farm.
Comments
Good question about the "deliberate balloon-floating." Q: Do you notice the anger if Mr. Hagel is not allowed to speak and represent a nomination? Also: The issue posed by the intimidators' method as we watch them up close here in the US: if we start connecting their ideas and methods with that of the State of Israel, that revelation can do a lot of harm (my opinion).Q: Is this about more weapon transfers or funding for the Irone Dome? Thanks, T.
-
I agree with your post! Evrything about your article is true. I was able to understand your post and got information from it. Thanks a lot! palawan tours palawan packages
For those of us with Suzuki Outboards Sale a reasonable fear of the ocean, this is a worst case scenario: Last week, Dan Suski, 30, and his sister Kate Suski, 39, chartered a fishing boat in St. Lucia. Things were going fine, despite the rough seas, and the siblings even managed to hook a 200-pound marlin. They were battling the giant fish when water rushed onto the boat and flooded its engine room. As the captain radioed for help, another surge Yamaha 4 Stroke Outboard of water swamped the boat. At that point, the captain tossed the Suskis life jackets and ordered them into the ocean. "He said, 'Jump out! Jump out!'" Kate Suski recalled in a telephone interview Thursday with The Associated Press. The captain and the first mate soon joined them and Yamaha 150 outboard, five minutes later, the boat sank, leaving the group stranded at least eight miles from shore. The group stayed put for the first hour, awaiting rescue. No one came. The group started to swim, but the rough waves caused the Suskis to became separated from the captain and first mate. "We would just see swells and gray," Dan Suski said. Hours went by. A helicopter and search plane arrived but failed to notice the two siblings. They continued swimming. Eventually, the sun went down. "There's this very real understanding that the situation is Yamaha outboard motors dire," Kate Suski said. "You come face-to-face with understanding your own mortality ... We both processed the possible ways we might die. Would we drown? Be eaten by a shark?" Neither could stop thinking about sharks. "I thought I was going to vomit I was so scared," Kate said. Finally, after 14 hours, they came within 30 feet of land only to discover the coast was covered with cliffs, making it impossible to climb from the ocean. “We knew we would get crushed,” Kate said. They kept swimming, Yamaha outboards Sale finally finding a small stretch of sand. Once ashore, they collapsed before again going into survival mode to avoid hypothermia. They hiked into the island and huddled together, covering themselves in grass and brush to stay warm. They spent the night like that, only moving when the sun rose. It took three hours before they found a farmer, who called police and gave them water and crackers. They would later find out that the captain and first mate had been rescued after 23 hours in the ocean. Despite dehydration, severe tendonitis and Honda outboards Sale cuts over their feet and back, the couple didn't blame anyone for the ordeal. "We are so grateful to be alive right now," Kate Suski said. "Nothing can sort of puncture that bubble."
Year 2013 is coming,the end of world(20/12/2012) was gone.We still live.2013 Yamaha Jet Ski Sale is listing now.We can supply the newest 2013 brand newand genuine Yamaha jet ski,Kawasaki Jet Ski Sale and Sea doo jet ski Sale with competitiveprice.The jet ski come with the trailer,cover and vest. Jet Ski For Sale, Kawasaki Jet Ski and Sea Doo Jet Ski are very popular all over theworld,especially European,Austrilia and USA.With jet ski,we can take waves stayed the speeding boats.We can communicate withthe sea. It’s a sunshine sport for every one who love sea.We can supply signal seat super 3 or 4 seats for the driver.We also can supply the best Yamaha Jet Boat and Sea Doo Jet Boat.It’s great to go with your girl friend to drive the jet boat on the sea.It’s romantic. 2013 Kawasaki Ultra 300X is well-know by every one who love jet ski.It’s a great one,the same as Sea Doo Jet Ski..We can supply the factory price and shipping free for you.
Efm is a shabbier elective to the standard rented line. Efm cost is a dependably on symmetrical administration that is uncontended and conveyed over copper instead of fibre.
candor group (Pvt) Ltd. professionals prepare a confidential candidate assessment report, which is then presented to the client for review. Candidate Identification and Assessment then follows. candor recruitment Group (Pvt) Ltd specialists contact, meet and assess a short list of potential candidates through telephone and personal interviews. Our Recruitment Business Management Outsourcing Group combining unparalleled experience, comprehensive capabilities across all industries and business functions, and extensive research on the world's most employment agencies, Candor Recruitment Group supports their clients to find job in the best companies of the world. Our employment services Management Outsourcing Group combining unparalleled experience, comprehensive capabilities across all industries and business functions, and extensive research on the world's most successful companies. Candor is the best in job placement agencies Human are the most important tool in Recruitment Agency Pakistan. Resourcing & Recruiting the most suitable manpower is the crucial part for companies.