Saleh Should Stay in New York

Accepting the ousted Yemeni president for medical treatment was a difficult, controversial choice. It was also the right one.

Ali Abdullah Saleh, the nominal president of Yemen, arrived in New York City last week. The visit is uncomfortable, to say the least.

For the past year, Saleh and his government resisted a peaceful protest movement’s calls for his resignation; months of stalemated sit-ins and marches that filled the thoroughfares of Sanaa, Ibb, Ta’iz and Aden were punctuated by massacres of civilians and street battles between the military and tribal militias. In November, after seven months of stalling, Saleh finally signed a transition agreement negotiated by the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) and supported by the United States. Under the terms of the agreement, Saleh agreed to pass his powers (though not his title) to his vice president while a jiggered “unity government” is formed and harried elections are conducted to authorize a new executive. In exchange, Saleh received immunity from prosecution, which was recently formalized in Yemeni law.

But the crisis in Yemen is hardly over. Protests persist, calling for Saleh to be held accountable for the violence against protesters. The presidential election is still a month out, and the only candidate will be the vice president and acting executive, Abed Rabbo Mansour Hadi.

Saleh is, at best, an erstwhile ally of the United States and an autocrat deposed by his own people. At worst, he is a war criminal responsible for the deaths of hundreds of his citizens and decades of misrule. It is no wonder that many analysts, including Gregory D. Johnsen, Paul Pillar, Andrew Exum, Marc Lynch, Will Picard, the Wall Street Journal editorial page and the Yemeni-American Coalition for Change, among others, have complained about the Obama administration’s decision to admit him to the country, a choice that has only been made worse by poor public relations and a seemingly clueless State Department. Saleh’s visit to New York should provoke discomfort and frustration. But it is also the right course.

The outrage about Saleh’s visit to the United States is two-fold. First, there is the anger that Saleh should be granted immunity under the terms of the deal supported by the United States and now ratified by the Yemeni parliament. Second, there’s the indignation that the United States would accept him here for treatment after his conduct over the past year. Both are understandable responses. Critics raise the legitimate concern that the decision will continue to stoke anti-American sentiments among the prodemocracy protesters in an extremely volatile country.

The United States needs to do more to engage the Yemeni public, but Washington should not confuse Yemen for a democracy. Nor is it on the cusp of becoming one. Yemen’s revolution is far removed from the clean break from autocracy that Tunisia seems to be making, or even from the entropic cycle of protests, crack-downs and ultimately democratic elections in Egypt. The Yemeni revolution has only unseated Saleh—it has yet to change the government or its institutions, and this will not change with an election in February. There will still be no seat at the table for the nonaligned popular movements, who have made the most sacrifices and feel wronged by Saleh’s amnesty. An election does not a democracy make.

Saleh’s Continuing Influence

Throughout Saleh’s thirty-three-year rule, and even before, Yemen’s government has been a military autocracy riding atop a system of tribal power sharing and patronage with, at times, the superficial veneer of democracy. The removal of one man will not change this structure. The dominant forces in the parliament, the General People’s Congress (GPC) and the Islah Party, both have deep roots in Yemen’s tribal oligarchy. And though Saleh has been removed from the presidency, he has not been removed from the government—he retains the chairmanship of his political party and the GPC, and his sons and nephew command branches of the Yemeni military. After decades of skillfully manipulating Yemeni politics, it seems unlikely he will stop now, despite rumors that he is considering exile in Oman.